How to Analyze a Rental Property
A rental is only a good deal if it pays you after every cost, including the ones that don't show up every month. This is the order most investors work through.
1. Estimate the rent
Look at what similar homes nearby actually rent for, not the highest listing. Check size, bedrooms, condition and school zone. Propistic shows an estimated market rent with each analysis.
2. List every expense
- Property taxes and insurance: get real quotes; both vary a lot by county and by flood zone.
- Vacancy: a share of the rent for the weeks between tenants.
- Repairs and maintenance, and capital expenses: money set aside for roofs, HVAC and water heaters, not just small fixes.
- Property management: even if you manage it yourself, count your time or plan for hiring out later.
- HOA, utilities you pay, lawn care and pest control.
3. Calculate net operating income (NOI)
NOI is the rent you collect minus operating expenses, before the mortgage. It's the number cap rate and DSCR are built on.
4. Check the key numbers
- Cash flow: NOI minus the loan payment. It should be positive with a cushion, not just above zero.
- Cap rate: NOI divided by the price. Useful for comparing properties regardless of financing. See cap rate vs. cash-on-cash.
- Cash-on-cash return: yearly cash flow divided by the cash you put in.
- DSCR: NOI divided by the yearly loan payments. Many rental lenders look for about 1.2 or higher. See DSCR loans explained.
5. Stress-test it
Rerun the numbers with lower rent, a higher interest rate and a bigger repair budget. A deal that only works in the best case isn't a deal.
Try the free Rental Property Calculator
Frequently asked questions
What is a good cash flow per door?
It depends on your market, price point and goals. Many investors set a minimum monthly cash flow after all expenses and reserves, and walk away from deals that don't clear it.
Should I include a vacancy allowance if the house is already rented?
Yes. Every tenant eventually leaves, and turnover usually brings both empty weeks and repair costs.