Your First Call With a Seller: What to Ask and What to Listen For
The first call isn't about making an offer. It's about understanding the house and the person well enough to know whether you can help, and earning a second conversation.
The four things you need to learn
| Topic | Ask | Listen for |
|---|---|---|
| Condition | "Walk me through the house. What would you fix if you were staying?" | Big items: roof, foundation, AC, plumbing, water damage. |
| Motivation | "What has you thinking about selling?" | The real problem, which is often the second answer, not the first. |
| Timeline | "If we agreed on everything, when would you want to close?" | A date tied to an event: a move, a tax deadline, an estate. |
| Price | "Do you have a number in mind?" | Whether it's based on a need (a payoff) or a hope (an online estimate). |
Talk less, ask more
- Ask one question, then wait. Silence gets you the real answer.
- Repeat back what you heard: "So the main thing is getting this done before the new job starts in March?"
- Never argue about value on the first call. Write the number down and do your homework.
- Be straight about what you are: "I buy contracts and work with a network of cash buyers; I may assign this contract." In Texas, you'll also have to tell the owner that in writing before you contract to assign.
End with a next step
Every call ends with a date: a walkthrough, a call back with numbers, or a follow-up next month. Write it down and keep it.
Take notes during the call on the property in your workspace, so your offer and your follow-up use the seller's own words.